2017 Spring GCLC All Stars
| Sport | Name | Year | Team |
| Boys Volleyball | Nick Beck | Senior | 1st |
| Jakob Jones | Junior | 2nd | |
| Softball | Harmonie Kugele | Junior | 1st |
| Arrington Walker | Freshman | 1st | |
| Ava Caldwell | Junior | 2nd | |
| Maddie Gullette | Junior | 2nd | |
| Haley Hoffman | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Baseball | Chris Hoffmann | Freshman | 1st |
| Jeordon Kuderer | Senior | 1st | |
| Brian Schnedl | Senior | 1st | |
| Tyler Bullock | Freshmen | 2nd | |
| Jake Speed | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Dylan Polk | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Track & Field | Austin Fulton | Junior | 2nd |
Additional Honors:
Tim McCoy – GCLC-Central Coach of the Year (Baseball)
2016-17 Winter GCLC All Stars
| Sport | Name | Year | Team |
| Boys Basketball | Craig McGee Jr. | Senior | 1st |
| James Johnson | Senior | 1st | |
| Alec Pfriem | Sophomore | 1st | |
| Justin Johnson | Senior | 2nd | |
| Girls Basketball | Kelly Brenner | Freshman | 1st |
| Jalyn Jackson | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Aliyah Huff | Senior | 2nd | |
| Swimming | Ben Enderle (200 IM) | Junior | 2nd |
| Sophie Hunter (100 Breaststroke) | Junior | 2nd | |
| Bowling | Taylor McIntosh | Senior | 1st |
| Ethan Nye | Junior | 1st | |
| Lydia Trentman | Junior | 1st | |
| Kobe Taylor | Junior | 2nd | |
| Anna Perry | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Melanie Petrey | Junior | 2nd | |
| Wrestling | Jake Mumper | Freshman | 2nd |
| Zac Baur | Senior | 2nd |
Additional Honors:
Craig McGee Jr – GCLC-Central Player of the Year (Boys Basketball)
Brian Neal – GCLC-Central Coach of the Year (Boys Basketball)
Jacob Cheesman – GCLC-Central Coach of the Year (Girls Basketball)
2016 Fall GCLC All Stars
| Sport | Name | Year | Team |
| Football | Clark Willhoite | Senior | 1st |
| Zac Baur | Senior | 1st | |
| Trey Hennekes | Senior | 1st | |
| Jeordon Kuderer | Senior | 1st | |
| Mike Hill | Senior | 1st | |
| Hazen Petit | Senior | 1st | |
| Amari Rogers | Senior | 1st | |
| Kobe Taylor | Junior | 2nd | |
| Logan Wolf | Junior | 2nd | |
| Amari Rogers | Senior | 2nd | |
| Thomas Curtis | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Zach Whitton | Junior | 2nd | |
| Girls Volleyball | Courtney Niesen | Senior | 1st |
| Maddie Gullette | Junior | 1st | |
| Olivia Stark | Senior | 1st | |
| Mary Kate Dewees | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Harmonie Kugele | Junior | 2nd | |
| Girls Soccer | Renee Finan | Senior | 1st |
| Kaylee Sunders | Junior | 1st | |
| Natalie Geers | Senior | 2nd | |
| Olivia Horton | Senior | 2nd | |
| Boys Soccer | Ethan Hay | Senior | 1st |
| Austin Fulton | Junior | 1st | |
| Sam Johnstone | Senior | 1st | |
| Alex Chittum | Senior | 1st | |
| Adam Eckart | Senior | 2nd | |
| Brandon Beck | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Gideon Fomba | Sophomore | 2nd | |
| Kingsley Fomba | Sophomore | 2nd |
Cincinnati Enquirer Fall All-City honors
| Sport | Name | Year | Team |
| Football | Trey Hennekes | Senior | 1st |
| Hazen Petit | Senior | 1st | |
| Girls Volleyball | Courtney Niesen | Senior | 1st |
| Mary Kate DeWees | Sophomore | 1st | |
| Maddie Gullette | Junior | Honorable Mention | |
| Olivia Stark | Senior | Honorable Mention | |
| Girls Soccer | Kaylee Sunders | Junior | 1st |
| Olivia Horton | Senior | Honorable Mention | |
| Renee Finan | Senior | Honorable Mention | |
| Boys Soccer | Ethan Hay | Senior | 1st |
| Austin Fulton | Junior | 1st | |
| Alex Chittum | Senior | 2nd | |
| Sam Johnstone | Senior | 2nd | |
| Gideon Fomba | Sophomore | Honorable Mention | |
| Adam Eckart | Senior | Honorable Mention |
Additional Honors:
Trey Hennekes – Offensive Player of the Year (Footbal)
Hazen Petit – Defensive Player of the Year (Football)
Mike Braun – Coach of the Year (Boys Soccer)
Ethan Hay – DIII 1st Team All-Ohio
Kaylee Sunders – DIII 2ns Team All-Ohio
Kaylee Sunders & Renee Finan – All SW District Team
SW District DIII Private School COY – Tom Eckart (Girls Soccer)
SW District DIII Private School ACOY – Dick Arszman (Girls Soccer)
All Ohio Academic Honors – Liza Hoopes, Renee Finan, Abby Merz, Lindsey Kroeger, Hannah Funk & Olivia Horton (Girls Soccer)